To print or not to print a social media icon, that is the question.
26 Jun
I took this photo at the gas pump this morning. It didn’t set right with me. This was an sticker advertisement for a fuel supplement and the designer appended the default social icon trio to the bottom of the ad. I stared at this while my gas was pumping (sans the fuel supplement) and tried to figure out why this irked me so much.
Frankly, I don’t mind social icons on websites that much as they serve the function of directing a user to a certain URL. Placing social icons on print collateral seems to be counter-intuitive to me. The default web behavior is to click on the icon and find pure social awesomeness (or not) beyond the home page. The printed icons in question are commonly used on websites everywhere. There was a dissonance in my brain where Mr. Subconscious was saying “Click click clickety click those bad boys” the Mr. Conscious was retorting “Idiot, this is a print ad.”
The cardinal sin of this ad is they have required the user to go on a clueless scavenger hunt. They are technically saying, “We’re somewhere in the adjacent galaxies of Twitter, Facebook, and YouTube, now come find us. We hope you remember the name of our product for your search.” This creative director had a misfire on one of their cylinders when approving this ad. It is tantamount to telling the customer, “We have a store in the United States. We’re not going to tell you where it is, but we’re going to represent its location with this awesome Google Maps icon that tells you we are super duper tech savvy.”
The bottom line for me is placing social media icons on print media is simply ineffective without…usernames. Icons without context never get searched. People will remember a simple user name like SaveMoneyOnGas, but probably won’t remember to search “Super Mileage Booster Fuel Supplement Twitter Feed.” The point of all of this is what we do on the web doesn’t always translate to other forms of media. You have to adjust for the user experience by supplying enough information in each media form. These days, it’s extremely probable that your print media won’t make it to the user’s office space, therefore rendering your cute, cuddly icons useless.
Don’t be one of “those” that just drag and drop the cliche’ social media icon trio into everything you do without thinking about its user experience ramifications. My personal thought is that people who overuse social media icons for the sake of proving their techno guru-ness are trying to compensate for not being tech savvy at all. Any thoughts from the peanut gallery?





MagCloud is a sweet, novelty service that allows you to create a real magazine. The process seems pretty straight forward.
I have had many people ask me to educate them on my experience with commercial printers. It’s a scary business to break into if you have no experience. I have worked with printers for the better part of a decade now. I’ve learned the hard way and messed up a few jobs. Hopefully, I can help you so you don’t make the same mistakes I did.

